Collision vs. Comprehensive Car Insurance: What’s the Difference?

It’s simple to confuse them. They each begin with the letter “C” they usually’re each types of car insurance that cowl harm to your automotive solely, however that’s the place their similarities finish. So as to add to the confusion, automotive insurance coverage corporations normally bundle complete and collision insurance coverage collectively.

So, what’s the distinction between collision vs. complete automotive insurance coverage? Prepare for a kind of explanations that once you hear it, you understand, oh, that makes good sense!

Let’s go over the fundamentals and clear up the confusion.

What Is Complete Insurance coverage?

The only solution to clarify comprehensive car insurance is to say that it covers harm—to your automotive solely—that’s brought on by one thing aside from a collision with one other automotive.

Don’t let car insurance costs get you down! Download our checklist for easy ways to save.

It might be a pure catastrophe, theft, harm from hitting an animal, vandalism, act of terrorism or a falling object. So, in case your automotive will get broken in a twister, is stolen from the airport long-term parking zone, or your new paint job will get “keyed,” you’d be coated by complete insurance coverage. (Extraordinarily unfortunate however coated!)

Complete insurance coverage occasions are generally known as “acts of God” since you haven’t any management over them. More than likely, you’re not even round after they occur.

The principle advantage of complete insurance coverage is to offer you peace of thoughts and monetary safety if one thing actually unfortunate occurs to your automotive.

What Is Collision Insurance coverage?

Collision insurance covers restore or alternative prices—to your automotive solely—in the event you trigger harm to your automotive by colliding with one other automobile or an object like a tree, fence or visitors barrier. A great way to recollect this sort of insurance coverage is that you’ve got management over the collision. (Aspect be aware: Hitting a deer or different animal is roofed by complete. It would look like it’d fall beneath collision however consider it like this: The deer is working into you. You don’t have management over that.)

Let’s say you sideswipe a guardrail at excessive pace. In case you have collision insurance coverage all you’re liable for is paying your deductible, and your insurance coverage firm will cowl the fee to restore your automotive.

The principle advantages of carrying collision insurance coverage are peace of thoughts that you simply received’t must pay excessive restore prices, and sometimes, that you simply received’t must take care of one other driver’s insurance coverage firm.

What’s the Distinction Between Complete vs. Collision Insurance coverage?

The principle distinction between collision vs. complete insurance coverage is that collision insurance coverage covers harm brought on when the motive force is answerable for the automotive, whereas complete protection typically covers occasions which might be out of the motive force’s management.

Let’s use a twister for instance the distinction between collision vs. complete insurance coverage. Think about the next two eventualities:

  1. A sofa from a house that was caught within the funnel of a twister falls in your automotive whereas it was parked in your driveway.
  2. You swerved to keep away from hitting a sofa that was caught within the funnel of a twister and drove right into a road pole.

In situation one, because you didn’t have management over the falling sofa, your insurance coverage firm would reimburse you for damages to your automotive beneath your complete automotive insurance coverage.

In situation two, you did have management over your automotive in that state of affairs, so your insurance coverage firm would reimburse you for harm to your automotive from the road pole beneath your collision protection.

What Do Complete and Collision Insurance coverage Cowl?

Collectively, complete and collision insurance coverage (mixed with the required legal responsibility insurance coverage) is known as full protection. Right here’s a chart that reveals what complete and collision insurance coverage cowl individually.

collision vs comprehensive car insurance coverageWe suggest connecting with one of our Endorsed Local Providers (ELPs) to seek out the most effective value for complete and collision protection.

Do I Want Complete and Collision Insurance coverage?

When you’re questioning whether or not each forms of protection are essential, the reply is sort of at all times sure. Each forms of harm are frequent, so we do recommend carrying comprehensive and collision insurance typically. Right here’s why.

Your Monetary Scenario

In case your automotive is totaled, are you able to afford to interchange it with out going into debt? It’s an disagreeable thought, however automotive accidents occur on a regular basis. In case your reply isn’t any, then that’s a threat you don’t have to take. Get complete and collision protection so the insurance coverage firm may also help together with your automotive’s alternative price and you’ll preserve your emergency fund for an additional time. The one exception to that is in case your automotive is paid for and never price very a lot, and you possibly can simply afford to interchange it. In that case, you possibly can skip complete and collision.”

Your Driving Habits

Do you have got a protracted commute to work or a relationship with somebody in a special metropolis? In that case, consider (as you’re caught in freeway visitors, but once more) that the extra you drive, the upper the chance of injury to your automotive, and the extra possible you’ll want to purchase complete and collision insurance coverage.

The place You Stay

Your location has so much to do with shopping for automotive insurance coverage protection. Even in the event you don’t drive that always, in the event you reside in an space that has a excessive crime charge or is susceptible to pure disasters, it is best to at the least purchase complete insurance coverage.

How Your Automotive Is Financed

When you lease or finance your car, the lender will most probably require that you simply carry complete and collision insurance coverage. Lenders wish to be sure they’re not in danger in case your automotive is totaled or stolen, and also you stroll away out of your mortgage or lease.

When you own your car (the higher monetary selection!), you’re not required by regulation to hold complete or collision insurance coverage, however once more—in the event you can’t afford to pay to restore or substitute your automotive by yourself, it’s too dangerous to go with out the fitting protection.

How A lot Does Complete and Collision Insurance coverage Price?

Generally, collision insurance coverage is costlier than complete insurance coverage as a result of collision claims are extra frequent than complete claims. Let’s have a look at the typical charges in every state.


Common Annual Collision Premium

Common Annual Complete Premium

























District of Columbia































































New Hampshire



New Jersey



New Mexico



New York



North Carolina



North Dakota















Rhode Island



South Carolina



South Dakota





















West Virginia









* Statistics are from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Get the Greatest Protection for the Greatest Value

We suggest carrying each complete and collision insurance coverage. Sure, the 2 forms of protection are completely different, however they’ll each shield your emergency fund within the occasion of serious harm to your automotive.

Connect with one of our Endorsed Local Providers (ELPs) who can discover the most effective charges for complete and collision insurance coverage in your state. Our ELPs are impartial brokers, that means they will be just right for you, not the insurance coverage firm.

Leave a Comment